Tech Report

Analysing the Usability of a Design Rationale Notation

Semiformal, argumentation-based notations are one of the main classes of formalism currently being used to represent design rationale (DR). However, our understanding of the demands on designers of using such representations has to date been drawn largely from informal and anecdotal evidence. One way to tackle the fundamental challenge of reducing DR's representational overheads, is to understand the relationship between designing, and the idea structuring tasks introduced by a semiformal DR notation. Empirically based analyses of DR in use can therefore inform the design of the notations in order to turn the structuring effort to the designers' advantage. This is the approach taken in this chapter, which examines how designers use a DR notation during design problem solving.

Two empirical studies of DR-use are reported, in which designers used the QOC notation (MacLean et al., this volume) to express rationale for their designs. In the first study, a substantial and consistent body of evidence was gathered, describing the demands of the core representational tasks in using QOC, and the variety of strategies which designers adopt in externalising ideas. The second study suggests that an argumentation-based design model based around laying out discrete, competing Options is inappropriate during a depth-first, `evolutionary' mode of working, centered around developing a single, complex Option. In addition, the data provide motivation for several extensions to the basic QOC notation. The chapter concludes by comparing the account of the QOC-design relationship which emerges from these studies, with reports of other DR approaches in use.

Publication(s)

A revised version of this is to appear as a chapter in "Design Rationale: Concepts, Techniques and Use", Moran T.P. and Carroll J.M. (Eds.). Lawrence Erlbaum Associates: NJ (in press)

ID: kmi-95-13

Date: 1995

Author(s): Simon Buckingham Shum

Resources:

View By

Other Publications

Jobs

Senior Research Fellow x 2

Knowledge Media Institute (KMi)
50,618 - 56,950 (Grade AC4)
Based in Milton Keynes
Permanent Position

WE ACCEPT APPLICATIONS FROM CITIZENS GLOBALLY The Knowledge Media Institute (KMi) is one of the top research centres in the world in the area of knowledge and media technologies, and we offer a creative and flexible working environment. The style, impact and content of our work are described in detail at http://kmi.open.ac.uk/ Your goal is to strengthen KMi's international research reputation and in particular pursue a robust and innovative research agenda in one or more of these...

Research Assistant / Associate

Knowledge Media Institute (KMi)
29.799 - 38,833 (Grade AC1 / AC2)
Based in Milton Keynes
Temporary contract until 30th November 2018

WE ACCEPT APPLICATIONS FROM CITIZENS GLOBALLY The Knowledge Media Institute (KMi) is a distinct research unit within the Faculty of Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM) at the Open University. KMi is looking for a Research Assistant or a Research Associate to work on the project Analytics For Everyday Learning. The AFEL Project is an innovative EU funded research project with 5 partners from the UK, Germany, Spain, and Austria. Its goal is to identify the features that...

Research Assistant / Associate

Knowledge Media Institute (KMi)
29,799 - 38,833 (Grade AC1 / AC2)
Based in Milton Keynes
Temporary contract until 31st December 2018

WE ACCEPT APPLICATIONS FROM CITIZENS GLOBALLY The Knowledge Media Institute (KMi) is a distinct research unit within the Faculty of Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM) at the Open University. KMi is looking for a Research Assistant or a Research Associate to work on the OU ANALYSE project (http://analyse.kmi.open.ac.uk). The aim of the project is to increase the retention rate at the OU and at the same time to improve the quality of education. Internet technologies...

CONTACT US

Knowledge Media Institute
The Open University
Walton Hall
Milton Keynes
MK7 6AA
United Kingdom

Tel: +44 (0)1908 653800

Fax: +44 (0)1908 653169

Email: KMi Support

COMMENT

If you have any comments, suggestions or general feedback regarding our website, please email us at the address below.

Email: KMi Development Team